← In The Field
In The Field

In The Field 031: I Asked To Cancel. They Sent Me My Password

3 min read
A high-tech digital security concepts blog hero image featuring an open email envelope with a glowing plain-text password typed out inside, symbolizing a data leak and poor security practices, sleek conceptual visual style.

A high-tech digital security concepts blog hero image featuring an open email envelope with a glowing plain-text password typed out inside, symbolizing a data leak and poor security practices, sleek conceptual visual style.

I subscribed to an RFP listing service called FindRFP. It wasn’t useful for my business, so I went to cancel. I could not find a way to do it anywhere on the site, so I emailed their support and asked them to cancel my subscription.

Here is what came back.

The support reply from FindRFP, with the login and password redacted

Instructions for where the cancel option lives, which is fine. And then my username and my full password, typed out in plain text in the body of an email.

I did not ask for my password. I asked to cancel.

Why That Is A Problem

Websites are not supposed to know your password. That has been the accepted standard for well over a decade.

A properly built login system stores a scrambled version of it, called a hash. When you log in, the system scrambles what you typed the same way and checks whether the two match. Properly built systems also add a random value, called a salt, to each password before hashing it, so two people with the same password never end up with the same stored value. Together, that practice is called hash and salt. The company never needs to see your real password, and a properly built system cannot show it to anyone, including its own support staff.

That is why a well run site never emails you your password. It sends you a link to set a new one.

The password in that email is the one I created when I signed up. They did not reset it. They read it back to me.

That means FindRFP stores passwords in a form its own staff can see, and anyone who ever gets into its database can see them too.

Why It Matters To You

If a company can read your password, so can anyone who gets into that company’s database, or into a support inbox. And email is not a secure channel. That password now sits in my inbox and in theirs, possibly forever.

Most people reuse passwords. If that password also opens their email, their bank, or their business accounts, one careless support reply exposes all of it.

The Cancel Button Nobody Could Find

The cancel option exists. It is on the My Account page, under Account Profile.

I build websites for a living and still could not find it without writing to support.

A subscription that is easy to start and hard to stop is a choice someone made.

If A Company Ever Emails You Your Password

The Foundation Connection

Security is part of a Digital Foundation, and most of it is invisible. You cannot see how a company stores your password. Sometimes, though, they tell you without meaning to.

If any company can tell you your password, it is storing it wrong.

I recommend checking your email address regularly at Have I Been Pwned. It is a free service that tells you when your address shows up in a known data breach.

Our In The Field posts describe problems we see every day. Many of these problems are solved when people follow proper standards. Ours are right here. See our standards →

Terms Used in This Post
Digital Foundation
A Digital Foundation is the underlying technical infrastructure that determines a business's visibility, security, and deliverability. It is the "chassis" of your online presence, if the foundation is cracked with poor code, badly managed GBP, missing security protocols, or broken DNS, no amount of marketing or pretty pictures will make the business successful.
Password Manager
A password manager is an app that creates and remembers a different strong password for every account, locked behind one master password or the phone's fingerprint or face unlock. It fills logins in for you, so using a unique password everywhere costs no extra effort, and one leaked password no longer opens everything else.
Hash and Salt
Hash and salt is how a properly built login system stores passwords. The password is mixed with a random value, the salt, and run through a one-way scramble, the hash. Only the result is kept. The system can check a password typed at login against it, but nobody, including the company's own staff, can turn it back into the password.
Data Breach
A data breach is when information a company holds, such as names, email addresses, passwords or payment details, ends up in the hands of people who were never meant to have it. It can come from an attack, a misconfigured server or a careless employee. Once data is out, it is usually sold and traded for years.
Plain Text
Plain text is information stored or sent exactly as it was typed, readable by anyone who sees it. For passwords it is the wrong way to store them: a company keeping passwords in plain text can read every customer's password, and so can anyone who gets into its database or its support inbox.
For business owners

Does Google know what your business is?

Most of the small business sites we open for the first time have the same handful of problems: email that lands in spam, a site that says nothing about where the business is, or a setting that tells Google to stay away. The free check reads your domain and lists what it finds. One box, no account, about a minute.

BizPinPro, Dublin, Virginia. Phone and email questions are always free.

Find us on